Digital Marketing for Creatives

If you’re an artist or author, you know the drill. The blank page, the empty canvas—these are your natural habitats. But in the 21st century, so is the endless scroll of social media. What starts as a joyful act of sharing your work can quickly morph into a source of anxiety, comparison, and time-sucking confusion.

You post, and then you wait. Sometimes, a piece you poured your soul into gets a few polite likes. Other times, a quick sketch or a random thought explodes. The algorithm feels like a fickle god, and you’re left wondering: “What am I even doing here? Is any of this actually helping my creative career?”

The answer is a resounding maybe. But “maybe” isn’t good enough for the precious hours you steal away from your studio or writing desk.

It’s time to stop guessing and start knowing. It’s time to conduct a Social Media Audit.

Think of this not as a punitive report card, but as a creative project in itself. It’s a deep, reflective look at your digital footprint with the goal of creating a more intentional, effective, and—dare we say—enjoyable social media presence. This is your compass. It will help you navigate away from the noise and toward a strategy that truly serves your art and your audience.

Why an Audit? Moving from Chaos to Clarity

Before we dive into the “how,” let’s solidify the “why.” For a creative, a social media audit isn’t about corporate metrics; it’s about aligning your online presence with your creative mission.

1. Reclaim Your Time and Mental Energy: Social media is a notorious time-thief. An audit helps you identify what’s working so you can do more of that and less of the stuff that drains you for no return. This frees up mental space and literal hours for your actual craft.
2. Refine Your Authentic Voice: As you evolve, your art evolves. Your social media should, too. An audit helps you see if your online voice still matches the artist or author you are today. It’s a chance to shed an old skin and present your most current self.
3. Understand Your Audience (and Find Your True Fans): Who is really engaging with your work? An audit moves you beyond follower counts to see the people behind the numbers. You’ll discover which followers are fellow creators, which are avid collectors/readers, and which are your most valuable cheerleaders.
4. Drive Meaningful Action: Is your goal to sell paintings, get your book into hands, grow your newsletter, or attract an agent? An audit shows you if your social media is actually guiding people toward these goals or just serving as a digital portfolio no one visits.
5. Make Informed Decisions: Instead of following the latest “post this to go viral!” trend, you’ll have your own data. You’ll know what your audience loves from you, allowing you to create a content plan with confidence.

The Pre-Audit: Gathering Your Tools and Setting Your Intentions

You don’t need expensive software. For a creative audit, your most important tools are your curiosity and a critical yet compassionate eye.

What You’ll Need:

• A Spreadsheet: Google Sheets or Excel is perfect. We’ll use it to log and analyze data.
• A Notebook or Document: For qualitative thoughts, ideas, and “aha!” moments.
• Dedicated Time: Block out 2-3 hours of uninterrupted time. Pour a cup of tea, put on some ambient music, and treat this like a research session for your creative business.

Define Your “Why”:
Before you look at a single post, answer this: What is the primary goal of my social media presence right now?
Be specific. It could be:

• “To sell my original artwork.”
• “To build an email list for my upcoming book launch.”
• “To connect with other fantasy authors for support and cross-promotion.”
• “To attract the attention of a literary agent or gallery curator.”
• “To establish myself as an expert in [your niche, e.g., botanical illustration].”

Write this goal at the top of your notebook. This is your guiding star for the entire audit.

---

The Actionable Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide for Creatives

We’ll break this down into four key phases: The Bird’s-Eye View, The Platform Deep Dive, The Competitive Lens, and The Synthesis.

Phase 1: The Bird’s-Eye View — Mapping Your Digital Territory

First, let’s see the whole landscape.

Step 1: The Inventory List
Make a list of every social platform where you have a presence, no matter how dormant. Instagram, Twitter/X, Facebook, TikTok, Pinterest, LinkedIn, YouTube, your blog—all of it.

In your spreadsheet, create columns for:

• Platform
• Username/Handle
• Follower Count (as of today)
• Primary Audience (e.g., “Readers,” “Fellow Artists,” “Clients”)
• My Goal for This Platform (e.g., “Inspiration & Community” for Instagram, “Professional Networking” for LinkedIn)
• Time Spent Weekly (be honest!)
• Energy Level (Rate it: High, Medium, Low. Does it energize or drain you?)

Step 2: The Relevancy Check
Now, review this list with a ruthless eye for alignment. Does maintaining a presence on each platform serve the “Primary Goal” you defined earlier?

• High Alignment, High Energy: These are your priority platforms. (e.g., A visual artist finding joy and sales on Instagram).
• High Alignment, Low Energy: These need a strategy tweak. Why is it draining? Can you change your approach? (e.g., An author who knows they need Twitter but finds it toxic might decide to use it only for scheduled promo and curated lists).
• Low Alignment, High Energy: This is a trap! You might enjoy the platform, but if it’s not serving your core audience or goal, it’s a distraction. Consider drastically reducing your time here. (e.g., Spending hours on a gaming Discord when your goal is to sell watercolor landscapes).
• Low Alignment, Low Energy: These are your candidates for deletion or “digital hibernation.” There is no shame in closing an account that no longer serves you. It’s a declaration of creative intent.

Actionable Tip: Based on this, decide on your Core 1-2 Platforms. You cannot be everywhere at once. Focus your best energy on the places that matter most.

Phase 2: The Platform Deep Dive — Listening to the Story Your Data Tells

Now, choose your one or two “Core Platforms” from Phase 1. We’re going to analyze the last 3-6 months of your activity on them.

Step 3: Content Performance Analysis
Go to your profile and scroll back. In your spreadsheet, create a new tab for this platform. Log your last 20-30 posts with columns for:

• Post Date
• Content Type (Photo, Reel, Carousel, Story, Thread, etc.)
• Topic/Subject (e.g., “Finished painting reveal,” “Work-in-progress video,” “Book quote,” “Personal story about creative block”)
• Caption Length (Short, Medium, Long)
• Call to Action (CTA) (What did you ask people to do? “Comment below,” “Visit my shop,” “None”)
• Likes/Hearts
• Comments
• Shares/Retweets
• Saves/Pins (This is a crucial metric for creatives—it means someone values your work enough to return to it.)

Step 4: Look for Patterns (The “Aha!” Moments)
This is the detective work. Look at your logged data and ask these questions:

• What are my Top 5 best-performing posts? What do they have in common? Was it the content type (e.g., Reels consistently outperform photos)? The topic (e.g., behind-the-scenes content gets more comments than finished pieces)? The time of day? A specific hashtag?
• What are my 5 lowest-performing posts? Is there a common thread? Maybe posts without a clear CTA flounder, or promotional-only posts get ignored.
• For Authors: Do posts about your main character get more engagement than world-building details? Do writing memes resonate more than your own text?
• For Artists: Do time-lapse videos of your process get more saves than photos of the final piece? Do posts about your inspiration spark more conversation than price announcements?

Actionable Tip: Don’t just count likes. Engagement rate is a better metric. (Likes + Comments + Shares) / Follower Count x 100. A post that gets 50 engagements with 1,000 followers (5% rate) is more impactful than one with 100 engagements and 10,000 followers (1%).

Step 5: Profile & Bio Diagnosis
Your bio is your digital handshake. Look at it with fresh eyes.

• Is it immediately clear what you do? “Artist” and “Writer” are fine, but can you be more specific? “Oil painter of moody landscapes” or “Author of cozy fantasy mysteries” is better.
• Does it reflect your current work? If you’ve moved from poetry to sci-fi novels, your bio needs to catch up.
• Is your link effective? A single link to a barren website is a dead end. Use a service like Linktree, Carrd, or Beacons to create a landing page with multiple options: your online shop, your latest book on Amazon, your newsletter sign-up, your commission info.
• Is your visual identity consistent? Profile picture, banner images, and highlight covers should feel like an extension of your artistic brand.

Phase 3: The Competitive Lens — Learning from Your Peers (Healthily)

This is not about comparison, which is the thief of joy. It’s about analysis. Pick 2-3 other artists or authors in your general niche whose social media presence you admire.

Step 6: Analyze Their Strategy
Spend 15 minutes on each of their profiles. Ask:

• What is their content mix? How much is promo, education, entertainment, personal storytelling?
• How do they use captions? Are they long and story-driven? Short and punchy?
• What is their visual style? Is it consistent? How does it make you feel?
• How do they engage with their audience? Do they reply to comments? Ask questions in their captions?
• What is their call to action? Where are they trying to drive traffic?

Actionable Tip: The goal here is not to copy them, but to identify patterns and opportunities. Maybe you notice they all use Instagram Stories polls to engage their audience—a tool you’ve never tried. This is about gathering intelligence to inform, not dictate, your own strategy.

Phase 4: The Synthesis — Creating Your Action Plan

You’ve gathered the data. You’ve spotted the patterns. Now, it’s time to build your new, intentional roadmap.

Step 7: Define Your New Content Pillars
Based on what you learned about your best-performing and most enjoyable content, define 3-5 “Content Pillars.” These are the core themes you will always talk about. This eliminates the “what do I post?!” panic.

• Example for an Artist:
  1. The Process: Studio shots, time-lapses, messy palette photos.
  2. The Finished Work: High-quality photos of completed pieces, with the story behind them.
  3. The Inspiration: Mood boards, nature walks, art history influences.
  4. The Artist’s Life: A personal touch—your favorite tea, a struggle you overcame.
• Example for an Author:
  1. The Writing Life: Desk setups, word count goals, struggles with editing.
  2. The World: Lore, character aesthetics, maps.
  3. The Book: Quotes, reviews, reading updates.
  4. The Reader’s Corner: Book recommendations, asking for opinions.

Step 8: Create a “Stop, Start, Continue” List
This is the heart of your action plan.

• STOP:
  • “Stop posting flat-lay photos of my supplies without any story. They perform poorly.”
  • “Stop spending time on [Platform X]. It’s a drain and doesn’t align with my goals.”
  • “Stop using 30 irrelevant hashtags on every post.”
• START:
  • “Start creating one process Reel per week, as video content engages my audience more.”
  • “Start using a clear CTA in every post (e.g., ‘Tap the link in my bio to read the first chapter’).”
  • “Start engaging with 5 new accounts in my niche for 10 minutes each day.”
• CONTINUE:
  • “Continue sharing personal stories about creative block—they spark the most meaningful conversations.”
  • “Continue using my ‘Behind the Canvas’ highlight on Instagram to showcase my process.”
  • “Continue posting my work-in-progress on Twitter—it’s where I get the best feedback.”

Step 9: Schedule Your Next Audit
A social media audit is not a one-time fix. Your art evolves, platforms change, audiences shift. Schedule your next audit for 6 months from now. Put it in your calendar.

Conclusion: Your Social Media, Back in Service of Your Art

You started this process feeling overwhelmed by the digital noise. You end it with a clear, compassionate, and data-informed plan. You have given yourself permission to quit the platforms that drain you, to double down on the content that fulfills you and connects with your audience, and to see your social media not as a distraction, but as a powerful extension of your creative studio.

The goal was never to become a viral sensation. The goal was to build a genuine community around your work, to find your people, and to ensure that the time you spend online is as intentional and purposeful as the time you spend creating.

Now, close the spreadsheet, put the phone away, and return to your craft. Your social media is no longer a mystery; it’s a managed tool. And you, the artist, the author, are back in control.

---

If you found this post useful, why not subscribe to get notified every time a new posts gets, er, posted. It’s free and totally spam free. Just pop your email address in the box below.