Why Your Creative Work Flops on Pinterest (And How to Fix It)

The Ultimate Guide to Going Viral as an Artist, Writer, or Maker

Pinterest is the most underrated platform for creatives. Unlike Instagram or TikTok, pins keep working for you for years—bringing free traffic, sales, and fans long after you post.

But most artists, authors, and makers use Pinterest completely wrong.

They:

Post blurry images with no keywords.
Ignore SEO (yes, Pinterest is a search engine!).
Give up after 5 pins because “Pinterest doesn’t work.”

The truth? Pinterest isn’t social media—it’s a visual search engine. And if you treat it like one, it can become your #1 source of passive traffic.

In this guide, you’ll learn:
✔ Why your pins aren’t getting seen (the 5 deadly mistakes).
✔ How to create pins that go viral (even with zero followers).
✔ The best tools & strategies for artists, writers, and makers.
✔ Real examples of creatives getting 100K+ monthly views.

Let’s fix your Pinterest strategy—for good.

Mistake #1: You’re Treating Pinterest Like Instagram

Instagram vs. Pinterest:

Instagram	Pinterest
Needs followers to see posts	Pins rank based on SEO, not followers
Posts die after 48 hours	Pins can go viral months later
Focused on “engagement”	Focused on saving & clicking

The Fix:

Stop worrying about followers. Focus on keywords and saves.
Design pins to look clickable (more on this below).

Mistake #2: Your Pins Are Invisible to Search

Pinterest is 85% SEO. If your pins don’t have keywords, they won’t be found.

How to Fix Your Pinterest SEO:

1. Use Keywords in These 4 Places:

✅ Pin title: “Surreal Cat Art Print | Dark Fantasy Wall Decor”
✅ Pin description: “This limited-edition surreal cat portrait is perfect for gothic art lovers. Available as a print, sticker, or phone case.”
✅ Board titles: “Dark Academia Art & Aesthetic” (not just “My Art”)
✅ Image alt text: Describe your pin for Pinterest’s crawler.

Tool: Use Pinterest’s own search bar to find trending keywords.

2. Target Long-Tail Keywords

❌ “fantasy art” (too competitive)
✅ “dark fantasy art of haunted libraries” (easier to rank)

Pro Tip: Look at autocomplete suggestions when typing in Pinterest’s search bar.

Mistake #3: Your Pins Aren’t “Clickable”

Pinterest is a visual platform, but most artists post:

Low-quality images.
No text overlay.
Boring compositions.

How to Make Pins That Stop Scrollers:

1. Use Bold Text Overlays

Example:
- ❌ A plain image of your painting.
- ✅ The same image with text: “The Story Behind This Haunted Painting”

2. Use the Right Dimensions

Best pin size: 1000x1500px (2:3 ratio).
Ideal fonts: Bold, easy-to-read (like Bebas Neue or Montserrat).

3. Test Different Styles

Before/After (e.g., sketch vs. final painting).
Step-by-Step (e.g., “How I Draw Fantasy Maps”).
Mood Boards (e.g., “Gothic Book Aesthetic”).

Tool: Use Canva’s Pinterest templates for pro designs.

Mistake #4: You’re Not Pinning Consistently

Pinterest rewards fresh content. If you pin once a month, you won’t get traction.

The Ideal Pinterest Schedule:

5-10 new pins per week (can be variations of the same piece).
Repin old content to keep it circulating.
Use a scheduler to stay consistent.

Tool: Try Tailwind (Pinterest’s recommended scheduler).

Mistake #5: You’re Not Driving Traffic to Your Site

Pinterest should send people to your shop, blog, or commission page. Most artists miss this step.

How to Turn Pinners Into Buyers:

✅ Link every pin to a product page, blog post, or landing page.
✅ Use “Rich Pins” to show real-time pricing (for Shopify/Etsy users).
✅ Add a call-to-action (e.g., “Swipe up to shop” or “Comment ‘ART’ for the link”).

Tool: Enable Rich Pins for automatic updates.

Case Study: How an Indie Author Got 500K Monthly Views

Keyword Research: Targeted “dark academia book recommendations”
Pin Design: Used moody book flat lays + bold text.
Link Strategy: Every pin led to her book’s Amazon page.
Consistency: Pinned 3x/week for 6 months.

Result: Her book sales tripled from Pinterest alone.

Pinterest Success Checklist for Creatives

✅ Treat Pinterest like a search engine, not social media.
✅ Use keywords in titles, descriptions, and boards.
✅ Design click-worthy pins (text + eye-catching images).
✅ Post 5-10 pins per week (use a scheduler).
✅ Always link pins to your website/shop.

Final Thought: Pinterest Is a Slow Burn—But Worth It

Unlike Instagram, Pinterest traffic compounds over time. One viral pin can bring sales for years.

Stop neglecting it. Start optimizing.

What’s your biggest Pinterest struggle? Comment below!

Also, why not subscribe to ensure you get all future posts direct to your inbox?

Digital Marketing for Creatives